專題評論
首頁  >  專題評論
2018/10/26
川普該如何解決與中國的不公平貿易?

How Trump Should Address Unfair Trade With China

Robert E. Scott是經濟政策研究所的高級經濟學家和貿易與製造政策研究主任。

 

During the 2016 presidential campaign, Donald Trump cited my research prominently when making the case that unfair trade with China had grievously hurt workers in the United States. It wasn’t the first time my research had been referenced during a political campaign; Hillary Clinton cited it in a similar manner in 2007. But it was the first time my data informed a subsequent executive branch policy that I view with dismay: namely, the Trump administration’s heavy-handed approach to trade, which has involved imposing $250 billion worth of tariffs on Chinese goods.

在2016年總統競選期間,唐納德·川普強調與中國的不公平貿易嚴重傷害美國工人時,顯眼地引用了我的研究。這不是我的研究第一次在政治競選期間被引用;2007年,希拉蕊·柯林頓(Hillary Clinton)也曾以類似的方式引用它。但這是第一次,我的數據所帶來的後續行政部門政策令我感到沮喪,也就是川普政府在貿易問題上採取的嚴厲手段,其中涉及對中國商品徵收的價值2500億美元關稅。

 

The president’s tariff approach ignores a more significant problem — the currency misalignment of the dollar and the Chinese yuan — and so could end up doing more harm than good.

總統的關稅方法忽視了一個更為重要的問題——美元和人民幣之間的貨幣偏差——因此可能最終造成弊大於利。

 

Mr. Trump’s presidential campaign sought to channel the anger of many Americans over unfair trade. I understand this anger, having documented in my research the millions of manufacturing jobs lost in the United States as a result of flawed trading relationships with China and Mexico. But rhetoric doesn’t always equal insight, and the president’s approach ignores two key facts.

川普的總統競選極力引發許多美國人對不公平貿易的憤怒。我理解這種憤怒,在我的研究中記錄了由於同中國和墨西哥的貿易關係存在缺陷,導致美國失去數百萬製造業工作崗位。但說辭並不總是等同於洞察力,總統的做法忽略了兩個關鍵事實。

 

First, trade deals on their own don’t have much potential to help America’s workers. Contemporary trade agreements may be nominally concerned with rules and tariffs, but their primary outcome has been to tilt the playing field in favor of foreign investors, which merely continues a cycle of outsourced production. Tinkering at the margins, as evidenced by recent rewrites of the United States-Korea Free Trade Agreement and the North American Free Trade Agreement, alters mostly just the optics of trade policy. It sends a message that the president is “being tough.” But it’s unlikely to have a meaningful impact.

首先,貿易協議本身在幫助美國工人方面並沒有太大潛力。當代貿易協定可能在名義上與規則和關稅有關,但它們的主要結果是讓競爭環境有利於外國投資者,這只是延續了一個外包生產的循環。最近的美韓自由貿易協定和北美自由貿易協定的重新簽訂證明,對條款進行修改,主要只是對貿易政策外表看上去的樣子做出了改動。它發出一個信號:總統「很強硬」。但它不太可能產生有意義的影響。

 

The second fact is that currency misalignment — not trade deals — is the single most important driver of growing United States trade deficits. From 1997 to 2014, China purchased $4 trillion in United States Treasury bills and other assets to bid up the value of the dollar relative to the Chinese yuan. (China sold some of its reserves in 2015 and 2016 to stabilize the yuan, but this year it again bought foreign assets to keep the yuan from rising.) This has made China’s currency artificially cheap, creating what is effectively a huge subsidy for Chinese exports to the United States. It also imposes a de facto tax on all United States exports to China.

第二個事實是,貨幣偏差——而不是貿易協議——是美國貿易逆差增長的最重要因素。從1997年到2014年,中國購買了4萬億美元的美國國債和其他資產,以提高美元相對於人民幣的價值。(中國在2015年和2016年出售了部分儲備來穩定人民幣,但今年它再次購買外國資產以防止人民幣升值。)這使得人民幣人為地貶值,相當於在對中國向美國的出口做出巨額補貼。它在事實上還等於對美國出口到中國的所有產品徵稅。

 

China is not the only country doing this. Between 2006 and 2013, central banks in roughly 20 nations including China financed virtually all of America’s trade deficit. Growing United States trade deficits with these countries now account for most of the five million manufacturing jobs — and nearly 90,000 factories — lost in the United States in the past two decades. As my latest research demonstrates, trade with China alone has eliminated 3.4 million jobs in the United States since 2001, affecting every state and congressional district. Notably, the hardest-hit industry was not toys or apparel, but computers and electronic parts — long thought to be a source of America’s competitive advantage. It lost 1.2 million jobs.

中國不是唯一這樣做的國家。2006年至2013年間,包括中國在內的約20個國家的中央銀行的出資幾乎造成了美國的所有貿易逆差。對於過去20年美國流失的500萬個製造業工作崗位,以及將近9萬家工廠,大部分要歸咎於美國對這些國家的貿易逆差增長。正如我最新的研究表明,自2001年以來,僅與中國的貿易已經令美國減少了340萬個工作崗位,影響到每個州和國會區。值得注意的是,受影響最嚴重的行業不是玩具或服裝,而是計算機和電子零件——它們長期以來被認為是美國競爭優勢的源泉。這個領域內失去了120萬個工作崗位。

 

Growing trade with low-wage countries like China has decimated the earnings of 100 million non-college-educated workers in the United States — two-thirds of the work force.

與中國這樣的低工資國家的貿易增長大大削弱了美國一億非大學畢業工人的收入——他們占勞動力的三分之二。

 

And job losses have devastated entire regions of America’s industrial heartland, especially in the upper Midwest. Not surprisingly, this includes some of the once reliably Democratic states that President Trump carried in the last election.

失業摧毀了美國工業中心地帶的大片區域,特別是中西部的北部。上次選舉中,這個地帶一些曾經忠於民主黨的州毫不意外地轉向了川普總統。

 

Although China is no longer officially manipulating the value of its currency, the dollar remains significantly overvalued — in part because China is sitting on more than $3 trillion in foreign assets. The dollar is now overvalued by at least 25 to 30 percent against not just the Chinese yuan but also the Japanese yen and the euro. Notably, the dollar has risen further since Mr. Trump was elected, increasing roughly 6 percent in trade-weighted value since January 2018 alone, which further encumbers domestic manufacturers.

雖然中國不再正式操縱其貨幣的價值,但美元仍然被嚴重高估——部分原因是中國擁有的外國資產超過3萬億美元。美元現在被高估了至少25%至30%,不僅是對人民幣,還有對日元和歐元。值得注意的是,自川普當選以來,美元進一步上漲,僅僅是自2018年1月以來,貿易加權價值就增加了約6%,這進一步阻礙了國內製造商。

 

Unfortunately, currency misalignment can’t be fixed by updating trade deals. It’s a global problem driven largely by continuing foreign demand for United States securities and financial assets. Since 2014, private foreign investment in American financial assets has increased the dollar’s real, trade-weighted value by 20 percent. The dollar must be realigned against not just the Chinese yuan but also against the currencies of countries that have been running chronic trade surpluses for many years.

不幸的是,貨幣偏差無法通過更新貿易協議來解決。這是一個全球問題,主要是由於外國對美國證券和金融資產的持續需求。自2014年以來,對美國金融資產的私人外國投資使美元的實際貿易加權價值增加了20%。美元必須不僅對人民幣調整匯率,還要同那些多年來與美國存在長期貿易順差的國家的貨幣調整匯率。

 

Previous Republican presidents have taken steps to tackle an overvalued dollar. (In 1971, for example, Richard Nixon imposed a temporary import surcharge on all imports; it led to an agreement four months later to lower the dollar’s value.) What’s required is the political will to stand up to powerful actors like Walmart and Apple that benefit from continued currency misalignment. The president should apply leverage on America’s trading partners — a fee on incoming foreign capital, tariff threats or coordinated currency intervention — to realign the dollar.

以前的共和黨總統也曾採取措施解決美元高估的問題。(例如,1971年,理查德·尼克森對所有進口產品徵收臨時進口附加稅;導致四個月後達成協議,降低美元價值。)這需要與沃爾瑪和蘋果等受益於持續貨幣偏差的大公司對抗的政治意志。總統應該對美國的貿易夥伴施加影響力——對湧入的外國資本收費、關稅威脅或協調一致的貨幣干預——以調整美元價值。

 

Congress could try to force the president’s hand, threatening to impose significant taxes on capital inflows to reduce demand for United States financial assets. But the authority to negotiate on currency rests in the hands of the executive.

國會可能會試圖迫使總統採取行動,威脅要對資本流入徵收重稅,以減少對美國金融資產的需求。但貨幣談判的權力掌握在行政部門手中。

 

And until President Trump grasps the severity of the dollar problem, making a “great deal” on trade agreements will matter little for United States manufacturers.

在川普總統理解美元問題的嚴重性之前,就貿易協定達成「大買賣」對美國製造商來說幾乎沒什麼意義。

 

文章連結:https://cn.nytimes.com/opinion/20181026/trump-unfair-trade-china/zh-hant/dual/

 

評論 89
kansas city royals adjustable hat name
2019/03/19
04:29:59
black and white air jordan 11 shoes uk,jordan superfly 4 royal blue,new nike air max mens trainers,air jordan 32 release date
kansas city royals adjustable hat name http://www.decaturdocs.com/kansas-city-royals-adjustable-hat-name-hat_uk
nike air max 98 all black shoes on sale
2019/03/18
17:09:09
adidas yeezy boost 350 19th february uk,wholesale nike free flyknit rn black and purple,nike magista onda halowki 2013,nike mercurial victory ic gold
nike air max 98 all black shoes on sale http://www.bamboopho.com/nike-air-max-98-all-black-shoes-on-sale-lebron_no
air jordan 31 black white shoes
2019/03/18
05:58:03
nike elastico release date email,black and brown asics gel quantum 360 mens,jordan team shoes history exam,adidas x 16.2 red and black
air jordan 31 black white shoes http://www.decaturdocs.com/air-jordan-31-black-white-shoes-school_uk
washington nationals titleist hat colors
2019/03/17
13:32:02
nike air jordan 1 retro mid white wolf grey for cheap,nike air presto all black buy,nike air more uptempo size 9,nike hypervenom phantom 2 total black
washington nationals titleist hat colors http://www.bamboopho.com/washington-nationals-titleist-hat-colors-hat_uk
nike free 5.0 black gold for canada
2019/03/17
11:32:16
retro jordan 4.5 all white red,mens adidas nmd xr1,nike what the kobe 8 replica,adidas predator remake 2016
nike free 5.0 black gold for canada http://www.bamboopho.com/nike-free-5.0-black-gold-for-canada-perfect_no
nike air max 90 red velvet
2019/03/14
04:08:55
nike air zoom pegasus 32 all grey red uk
2019/03/13
19:45:57
new york yankees mlb wool classic 59fifty cap sizes,miami dolphins camo hats uk,black leather atlanta braves hat meme,how to knit a easy baby hat
nike air zoom pegasus 32 all grey red uk http://www.nlbroofing.com/nike-air-zoom-pegasus-32-all-grey-red-uk-for_de
jordan 1 black gold custom
2019/03/13
07:14:02
nike air zoom 90 it black silver,jordan reveal review questions,air jordan womens clothing ltd,nike the premier fg boots all black uk
jordan 1 black gold custom http://www.newkauto.com/jordan-1-black-gold-custom-huarache_fr
nike premier ii ic all grey black
2019/03/13
02:34:44
nike zoom hypercross all black for cheap,all black air jordan extra fly,black and brown nike lunar hypergamer,nike roshe run gpx hero blue tiger camo
nike premier ii ic all grey black http://www.lwhitaker.com/nike-premier-ii-ic-all-grey-black-over_fr
nike jordan trainer 1 low michigan
2019/03/12
22:07:16
nike zoom kd 5 white black blue,jordan trainer 97,nike magista orden ag black and white,black and red ua air jordan 8 shoes uk
nike jordan trainer 1 low michigan http://www.kodakzam.com/nike-jordan-trainer-1-low-michigan-over_es
2014 new nfl jerseys denver broncos 18 peyton manning white platinum game jerseys
2019/03/12
10:57:46
nike air presto all black shoes,womens air jordan 1 retro all black shoes,nike lebron 12 miami dolphins,jordan superfly 5 black yellow shoes
2014 new nfl jerseys denver broncos 18 peyton manning white platinum game jerseys http://www.nlbroofing.com/2014-new-nfl-jerseys-denver-broncos-18-peyton-manning-white-platinum-game-jerseys-jersey_no
miami dolphins new hats doll
2019/03/12
01:45:30
nike elastico 3 indoor units,air jordan 9 low cheap white and gold shoes,nike free rn flyknit anthracite,curry 1 shoes for sale auckland
miami dolphins new hats doll http://www.diejuliy.com/miami-dolphins-new-hats-doll-hat_de
the hundreds raiders hat vietnam
2019/03/12
00:38:14
nike air max 90 white out for cheap
2019/03/11
17:08:32
green black under armour curry 2 5 for uk,nike orca racer,nike tanjun size 5.5,jordan 6 men white
nike air max 90 white out for cheap http://www.decaturdocs.com/nike-air-max-90-white-out-for-cheap-school_dk
nike womens magista opus movie
2019/03/11
08:20:45
youth nike detroit lions 93 kyle vanden bosch elite white nfl jersey sale
2019/03/10
15:51:02
nike air huarache run pa ethnic black hot lava,nike kyrie irving 1 all star fund,adidas pure boost dpr meaning origin,air max 97 us
youth nike detroit lions 93 kyle vanden bosch elite white nfl jersey sale http://www.bamboopho.com/youth-nike-detroit-lions-93-kyle-vanden-bosch-elite-white-nfl-jersey-sale-jersey_fr
nike air force 1 womens white yellow uk
2019/03/10
11:53:59
san diego padres 1998 world series hat xl,new york mets fedora hat mens,new york yankees cap color online,toronto blue jays hawaiian hat week
nike air force 1 womens white yellow uk http://www.kodakzam.com/nike-air-force-1-womens-white-yellow-uk-all_fr
uk blue shoes nike free run 3
2019/03/10
07:02:26
uk red sale adidas x,white grey red nike lebron ambassador 10,nike hyperdunk 2015 indonesia,wine and white jordan 1
uk blue shoes nike free run 3 http://www.lwhitaker.com/uk-blue-shoes-nike-free-run--3-all_fr
limited bernie kosar mens jersey cleveland browns 19 camo fashion black nfl
2019/03/10
04:08:30
adidas yeezy boost 750 hk,nike air foamposite one all black,nike air jordan flight 45 trk winterized,nike hypervenom phelon iii black pink shoes on sale
limited bernie kosar mens jersey cleveland browns 19 camo fashion black nfl http://www.diejuliy.com/limited-bernie-kosar-mens-jersey-cleveland-browns-19-camo-fashion-black-nfl-jersey_de
yeezy 350 trainers
2019/03/09
11:39:50
all brown latest air force one low men uk shoes
2019/03/09
01:18:01
adidas yeezy boost 350 off white nz,air huarache ultra femme,nike elastico warna pink uk,nike elastico superfly hyper punch for sale malaysia
all brown latest air force one low men uk shoes http://www.buceowayuu.com/all-brown-latest-air-force-one-low-men-uk-shoes-boots_fr
wholesale nike free flyknit 4.0 black blue brown
2019/03/08
23:27:02
nike air more uptempo nyc,all white adidas zx flux adv for uk,nike dunk sky high black grey for cheap,mercurial proximo ii cheap black and white shoes
wholesale nike free flyknit 4.0 black blue brown http://www.diejuliy.com/wholesale-nike-free-flyknit-4.0-black-blue-brown-cheap_es
toronto blue jays baseball hat pattern
2019/03/08
18:13:42
nike free 5.0 2015 schwarz,nike kobe 9 elite captain america again,jordan hoodie mens,wholesale jordan 17 all green
toronto blue jays baseball hat pattern http://www.kodakzam.com/toronto-blue-jays-baseball-hat-pattern-hat_fr
mercurial superfly quadra guide
2019/03/08
12:26:59
nike air foamposite one rust pink diamond
2019/03/08
10:44:50
wine and white asics gel lyte 3 womens,dunk sb high shoes all black white uk,nike magista opus rebel yell,nike hypervenom phinish australia price
nike air foamposite one rust pink diamond http://www.lookadapp.com/nike-air-foamposite-one-rust-pink-diamond-trainer_dk
nike free 5.0 flyknit women all white red uk
2019/03/08
05:41:41
lebron 9 p.s elite all black blue,cheap nike magista obra fg gold soccer cleats,nike kaishi 48.5,nike lunar force 1 duckboot black kaufen
nike free 5.0 flyknit women all white red uk http://www.bamboopho.com/nike-free-5.0-flyknit-women-all-white-red-uk-turf_uk
boston red sox cap space for rent
2019/03/08
05:41:31
nike blazer original,uk black and white shoes nike lebron soldier,jordan standard black gold shoes on sale,nike magista onda rebel sport psychology
boston red sox cap space for rent http://www.rusesilver.com/boston-red-sox-cap-space-for-rent-hat_no
nike mercurial online shopping
2019/03/02
17:56:19
air max 97 america,mettodasic air max,barato nike tiempo legend vi todas blanco,air jordan 11 negro patent
nike mercurial online shopping http://www.eimanshafamd.com/nike-mercurial-online-shopping-mujeres_fr
nike kyrie 3 maschio tutti nero
2019/03/01
02:18:32
air jordan 31 black red white on sale
2019/02/28
08:33:24
himmelen blå kvinners air jordan 4,nike air jordan 17 rød,nike mercurialx finale ii all rød,billig svart gull new balance stikkontakt
air jordan 31 black red white on sale http://www.geenreettedoen.com/air-jordan-31-black-red-white-on-sale-jordan_uk
elite danorris searcy youth jersey tennessee titans 21 home light blue nfl
2019/02/26
17:36:04
nike mercurial victory v astro,nike mercurial superfly vi bambini tutti bianca,nike tiempo legend vi soft ground,air jordan 13 retro gs bianca rosa
elite danorris searcy youth jersey tennessee titans 21 home light blue nfl http://www.biginkprints.com/elite-danorris-searcy-youth-jersey-tennessee-titans-21-home-light-blue-nfl-jersey_dk
nike kobe 10 elite cheap zed
2019/02/25
20:17:23
nike flyknit air max grau and schwarz
2019/02/25
05:16:05
air max 97 silber bullet italy,adidas x 16.1 tf alle blau,auslauf schuhe himmelblau nike lebron soldier 11 kinder,auslauf schuhe weiß schwarz adidas messi 16+
nike flyknit air max grau and schwarz http://www.chaddhuffman.com/nike-flyknit-air-max-grau-and-schwarz-sports_de
kobe 11 lilla hvit
2019/02/22
14:30:22
billig air jordan 31 hvid,air jordan cp3.x alle hvid,the jordan 4,billig stephen curry two low rød
kobe 11 lilla hvit http://www.eimanshafamd.com/kobe-11-lilla-hvit-negro_no
adidas predator 18.1 tf black gold white outlet shoes
2019/02/21
23:29:30
air jordan 1 retro high nouveau bianca,tutti verde new air jordan 6 uk scarpe,jordan 1 flight 4 burgundy,nike sb paul rodriguez9 nero and rosso
adidas predator 18.1 tf black gold white outlet shoes http://www.firehurney.com/adidas-predator-18.1-tf-black-gold-white-outlet-shoes-happy_en
nike hypervenom botitas 2015 mercadolibre
2019/02/21
12:39:03
nike kyrie 3 (gs) black pink outlet shoes,air jordan 31 (gs) black blue shoes,nike air flight huarache black red shoes,nike mercurial superfly v all blue for cheap
nike hypervenom botitas 2015 mercadolibre http://www.leadwirral.com/nike-hypervenom-botitas-2015-mercadolibre-retro_de
original all white nike pg 1 shoes
2019/02/20
19:32:27
yeezy boost 350 kids,gray gold nike air max kpu shoes for sale,nike flyknit roshe run mens uk,nike kobe 6 grinch for sale download
original all white nike pg 1 shoes http://www.mentomedia.org/original-all-white-nike-pg-1-shoes-karaoke_en
bianca blu nero new balance ms77
2019/02/20
18:56:13
uk scarpe nero oro adidas x 18.2 fg
2019/02/20
10:58:43
rockstar hats new era qld,new york yankees cap buy online course,minnesota twins adjustable hat rack,pittsburgh pirates flat top hat zombie 007
uk scarpe nero oro adidas x 18.2 fg http://www.bettsgallery.com/uk-scarpe-nero-oro-adidas-x-18.2-fg-sneakers_it
retro jordan 8 / viii all white black
2019/02/19
22:36:37
air max tailwind 8 mens grey for cheap
2019/02/19
10:39:25
nike lunar golf shoes replacement spikes,mens nike air jordan retro 11 low black white green red black,nike free run 5 amazon,nike free rn blue card
air max tailwind 8 mens grey for cheap http://www.carvingsaw.com/air-max-tailwind-8-mens-grey-for-cheap-trainers_en
svart oransje hvit under armour curry 3 uk sko
2019/02/19
09:38:40
nike tiempox finale sort blå brun for canada,wholesalg nike air max 87 kvinder hvid sort orange,nike air max dominate hvid sort blå for canada,nike hypervenom phinish fg hvid rød for canada
svart oransje hvit under armour curry 3 uk sko http://www.marissaibclc.org/svart-oransje-hvit-under-armour-curry-3-uk-sko-Ginobili_no
all rød nike free 5.0 v3 kvinners sko uk sko
2019/02/19
01:16:40
adidas copa 17.1 fg alle silber für canada,wholeverkauf nike lunarglide 7 schwarz blau braun,adidas adizero 99g alle rot für canada,adidas mundial goal schwarz and blau
all rød nike free 5.0 v3 kvinners sko uk sko http://www.marissaibclc.org/all-r%C3%B8d-nike-free-5.0-v3-kvinners-sko-uk-sko-Parker_no
jordan hat box game
2019/02/17
18:02:34
multicolor flyknit lunarepic
2019/02/17
09:13:33
new york yankees cap pink zebra,new york yankees puerto rico hat days 2017,how to make a no sew baby hat,new york yankees cap olx xl
multicolor flyknit lunarepic http://www.bettsgallery.com/multicolor-flyknit-lunarepic-sneakers_it
air jordan 13 grey toe grade school sneakers for australia
2019/02/16
17:29:08
jordan crib scarpe size 3,air jordan 1 high white elephant print shoes,jordan 12 retro white french blue shoes,jordan 8 black red white shoes
air jordan 13 grey toe grade school sneakers for australia http://www.gerdhotline.com/air-jordan-13-grey-toe-grade-school-sneakers-for-australia-runner_no
air jordan 18 unboxing
2019/02/16
08:40:23
texas rangers postseason hats xl,nike mens knit hat patterns,miami dolphins hat rack 04,new york yankees hats blue xbox 360
air jordan 18 unboxing http://www.clubofit.com/air-jordan-18-unboxing-ruby_de
cheap nike magista obra boots
2019/02/15
06:23:32
nike kyrie 1 brown orange
2019/02/15
06:01:44
kyrie irving in australia ,nike lunarepic flyknit canada app
nike kyrie 1 brown orange http://www.clubofit.com/nike-kyrie-1-brown-orange-beautiful_de
nike premier ii tf black blue canada shoes
2019/02/14
18:21:31
nike flyknit racer yupoo tk ,air jordan iso 2 quai 54
nike premier ii tf black blue canada shoes http://www.packmonitor.com/nike-premier-ii-tf-black-blue-canada-shoes-max_it
air lebron slippers alle rot schuhe
2019/02/14
07:14:59
mens nike air max direct ,nike air foamposite 2018 taiwan
air lebron slippers alle rot schuhe http://www.beanumber.com/air-lebron-slippers-alle-rot-schuhe-cheap_de
oakland as authentic hat covers
2019/02/13
19:38:19
nike hypervenom phelon youth gold ,adidas zx 700 ireland uk
oakland as authentic hat covers http://www.beanumber.com/oakland-as-authentic-hat-covers-hat_en
reebok arizona cardinals matt leinart 7 white replica jersey sale
2019/02/13
05:14:10
air jordan 4 bred size 9 ,air force 1 mid size 9
reebok arizona cardinals matt leinart 7 white replica jersey sale http://www.carvingsaw.com/reebok-arizona-cardinals-matt-leinart-7-white-replica-jersey-sale-jersey_ca
nike magista obra ii black gold for cheap
2019/02/12
15:33:10
nike air max 1 panda ,adidas crazy light boost 2.5 review
nike magista obra ii black gold for cheap http://www.packmonitor.com/nike-magista-obra-ii-black-gold-for-cheap-jordan_it
jordan 11 retro negro jade
2019/02/12
06:04:18
unterschied nike magista orden onda 2017 ,nike roshe run one flight weight and weight
jordan 11 retro negro jade http://www.beanumber.com/jordan-11-retro-negro-jade-cheap_es
nike air span ii black green for cheap
2019/02/11
20:14:31
tenis nike 5 elastico ,new balance 751 all black
nike air span ii black green for cheap http://www.geenreettedoen.com/nike-air-span-ii-black-green-for-cheap-shoes_uk
jordan 10 sølv rød svart
2019/02/11
19:14:13
nike magista obra hvid and lyserød,nike kobe 9(ⅸ) himmelblå,billig nike air max 270 hvid,jordan 10 herre
jordan 10 sølv rød svart http://www.degrootenv.com/jordan-10-s%C3%B8lv-r%C3%B8d-svart-negro_no
nike free trainer 5.0 new zealand
2019/02/11
08:42:34
air jordan 11 space jam gs ,nike mercurial vapor iii sport red
nike free trainer 5.0 new zealand http://www.mcdebougie.com/nike-free-trainer-5.0-new-zealand-films_uk
auslauf schuhe rot schwarz air jordan 12 (xii)
2019/02/10
22:40:36
nike air pegasus sneakers usa ,nike shox clearance mens size 13 review
auslauf schuhe rot schwarz air jordan 12 (xii) http://www.carvingsaw.com/auslauf-schuhe-rot-schwarz-air-jordan-12-%28xii%29-trainers_de
nike mercurial superfly cr7 black and blue shoes
2019/02/10
12:07:03
jordan slippers toddlers ,nike basketball shoes sale
nike mercurial superfly cr7 black and blue shoes http://www.gerdhotline.com/nike-mercurial-superfly-cr7-black-and-blue-shoes-zero_ca
nike air max thea speckled light bleu ice blanc
2019/02/10
03:20:04
nike jordan true flight black jack ,1 but nike tanjun
nike air max thea speckled light bleu ice blanc http://www.beanumber.com/nike-air-max-thea-speckled-light-bleu-ice-blanc-cheap_fr
womens nike free run 2 light grey purple black
2019/02/09
16:43:34
new balance 3090 womens all black ,nike roshe run flyknit light grey
womens nike free run 2 light grey purple black http://www.steineausrheine.com/womens-nike-free-run-2-light-grey-purple-black-mercurial_en
air jordan 4 laser outfit
2019/02/09
08:00:13
mercurial superfly fg football boots discount ,air jordan 13 9.5
air jordan 4 laser outfit http://www.leadwirral.com/air-jordan-4-laser-outfit-fusion_en
nike roshe run salmon rosa hvit kvinners trainers
2019/02/09
00:23:36
adidas french beige nmd for sale ,adidas nmd tricolor for sale philippines address
nike roshe run salmon rosa hvit kvinners trainers http://www.beanumber.com/nike-roshe-run-salmon-rosa-hvit-kvinners-trainers-cheap_no
chicago bulls knit hat with pom quests
2019/02/08
15:40:26
nike mercurial superfly njr ,adidas ultra boost white laceless jazz
chicago bulls knit hat with pom quests http://www.bettsgallery.com/chicago-bulls-knit-hat-with-pom-quests-hat_es
kobe sko size 3
2019/02/06
21:02:31
nike shox nz,jordan why not zer0.1 tout blanc,air max light nike,jordan son of mars low blanc cehommest
kobe sko size 3 http://www.mosignup.com/kobe-sko-size-3-negro_no
los angeles angels camo hat 40
2019/02/06
12:13:07
nike air max 90 essential womens shoe ,nike air trainer 1 49ers
los angeles angels camo hat 40 http://www.carvingsaegen.com/los-angeles-angels-camo-hat-40-hat_fr
jordan retro 6 zwart
2019/02/05
23:18:08
pittsburgh pirates bucket hat 2016
2019/02/05
19:18:33
nike air max 90 essential womens shoe ,nike air trainer 1 49ers
pittsburgh pirates bucket hat 2016 http://www.beanumber.com/pittsburgh-pirates-bucket-hat-2016-hat_de
american flag knit hat size chart
2019/02/05
10:11:09
nike air max 90 west year ,nike air pegasus quilted black
american flag knit hat size chart http://www.beanumber.com/american-flag-knit-hat-size-chart-hat_en
womens asics gel kayano 22 all blue outlet shoes
2019/02/05
01:32:48
nike dunk hi nylon premium ,adidas f50 messi edition
womens asics gel kayano 22 all blue outlet shoes http://www.geenreettedoen.com/womens-asics-gel-kayano-22-all-blue-outlet-shoes-happy_uk
jordan 9 low bianca chrome
2019/02/05
01:28:55
kaufen adidas yeezy,new jordan 5s,billig under armour clutchfit drive low grau,billig adidas protator accelerator grau
jordan 9 low bianca chrome http://www.mosignup.com/jordan-9-low-bianca-chrome-trainers_it
new era nfl knit hats review
2019/02/04
17:09:47
nike dunk sb low wolf grey ,nike kd 6 texas quizlet
new era nfl knit hats review http://www.beanumber.com/new-era-nfl-knit-hats-review-hat_en
spain all grey nike air more uptempo shoes
2019/02/04
08:03:43
nike air force 1 white metallic rose gold ,air force 1 wheat nike store
spain all grey nike air more uptempo shoes http://www.mcdebougie.com/spain-all-grey-nike-air-more-uptempo-shoes-films_uk
adidas ace 16+ purecontrol bambini tutti nero
2019/02/04
03:36:15
air jordan 6 rosso bianca,a buon mercato nike zoom flight bonafide viola,nike air presto oreo,a buon mercato adidas ace 17+ purecontrol femminile nero
adidas ace 16+ purecontrol bambini tutti nero http://www.degrootenv.com/adidas-ace-16%2B-purecontrol-bambini-tutti-nero-sneakers_it
new era nfl knit hats 2015
2019/02/04
00:37:47
jordan trainer essential ex ,nike air jordan retro 13 for sale
new era nfl knit hats 2015 http://www.carvingsaw.com/new-era-nfl-knit-hats-2015-hat_it
san diego padres hats brown vs board of education
2019/02/03
15:48:05
nike elastico superfly dark green 007 ,nike magista opus wide feet to cm
san diego padres hats brown vs board of education http://www.bnbpilipinas.com/san-diego-padres-hats-brown-vs-board-of-education-hat_en
billig nike lebron soldier 8 grå
2019/02/03
06:14:23
under armour curry sko hvit,air jordan 4 for sale,nike phantom vision academy df grey,billig stephen curry one rød
billig nike lebron soldier 8 grå http://www.deddimusic.com/billig-nike-lebron-soldier-8-gr%C3%A5-soccer_dk
興大附中-羅之佑
2019/01/13
10:50:36
此篇旨在說明美中貿易對美國的不良影響和總統川普所採取得因應措施。
兩大經濟體系之間長期存在著利與弊,全球化的結果導致美國本土企業轉向雇用中國低成本勞力,使美國人民的工作權利受到威脅,美國向中國進口的大量廉價產品衝擊了美國各企業,仿製品的流入也對智慧財產權產生嚴重的威脅,但在美國政府制裁中國的同時,美國企業也會因為成本提高而有所怨言,此次的美中貿易戰被視為是兩國政府的報復性手段,並非以促進兩國貿易經濟中的和平和對等為依歸,此舉使雙方經濟惡化,股市大跌,進而牽動其他各國的股市和幣值,兩大國的領導人在沒有經過審慎思慮所做出的一意孤行的決定使全體走向一個惡性循環。
興大附中 劉帷凱
2019/01/07
02:08:14
美中貿易之間的糾葛,牽扯到了許多不同的面相。
中國以前因為低工資,而讓外國公司十分覬覦這份低成本樂土,卻連帶的導致了他國的就業問題──特別是美國。
而其中,如颶風摧毀他們的工作,因為產業倒閉而失業的人們,看到那彷彿是救命曙光的川普,便紛紛投下了他們的決定。
而他所採取的措施,卻貌似是絲毫不沾邊,工人沒有實際受惠,實際上只讓川普表現了他的意志。
楊翔吏
2018/12/22
14:49:56
美國和中國的貿易關係,始終因為貿易逆差而牽動兩國國內外的事務,中國也透過購買美國公債,來藉此穩定人民幣對於美元的升貶,雖然近年中國的基本公資上升,但各國還是沒撤除工廠和資金,其中也包含美國的公司在內,然而在川普這商人出身的總統上任後,為提振國內經濟以及工作機會,更是提出關稅制裁等的大動作,逼迫中國妥協,川普這樣對中強硬的政策,是否能解決國內經濟的窘境仍是有許多不確定,應提出顧全各界的政策,以不波及這貿易戰之間的的各國,又能使兩方都能接受。
評論
TOP